"the real stars of Matthew Warchus's production are Rob Howell's sets and Jon Driscoll's video designs, which graphically recreate the kaleidoscopic frenzy of Manhattan life. This is a musical in which the eyes emphatically have it." The Guardian
"As the lovers separated by death, Richard Fleeshman and Caissie Levy need to ignite a touch more stage chemistry, and could usefully turn down the volume during the strident ballads... This may not be a great musical, but it is a highly entertaining one." The Daily Telegraph
"I'm afraid that my belief in this show as a bona fide piece of musical theatre had given up the ghost some time before Molly has to." The Independent